Question:
If guru’s teachings should be according to guru sadhu sastra, why did Srila Prabhupada introduce another standard of chanting (less rounds)? Harinama-cintamani (it is also sastra, isn’t it?) states that only 64 rounds bring the mind into proper condition. I mean original version not the ISKCON one…
Besides, had any of Prabhupada’s predecessors asked disciples to treat him like God? Maybe I omitted something, but I thought that humbleness had been very much appreciated by them.
I don’t want to undermine anybody’s authority by these questions. Simply, some matters aren’t clear for me…
One more question. Where did the idea of gurukula come from? It seems to be nothing else but making orphanages. Children aren’t in touch with parents and in this way they become emotionally hurt. I wouldn’t have excused my parents if they had sent me far away for my supposed well-being. I’ve heard, by the way, about many abuses against those children by so called spiritual teachers.
Is this for sure a spiritual process?
Answer:
Dear Bh. Vika,
Hare Krsna!
Thank you for your questions.
It is said that one should not give spiritual advice to a person if that person is not able to follow it, otherwise that person can become hopeless and give up spiritual practice altogether. Seeing the passionate and ignorant qualities of those who came to him in America, Srila Prabhupada adjusted this detail by giving us 16 rounds as minimum and also giving us a lot of practical devotional service. This has proven to be more suitable for us…we have to judge by the result. By the way how many rounds do you chant daily?
I see it seems inconceivable to you that one can ask his disciples to treat him as good as God and still remain humble in his own person. Well Srila Prabhupada did it, and I saw it with my own eyes. Visvanatha Chakravadi Thakur writes in his guruvastaka, which we sing daily, shaksad Hari, the disciple should see his guru as good as God. Why? Because he is the most confidential servant of God, the pure representative of God, whom God has sent to help us.
Once I was in Srila Prabhupada’s room when the mother of one devotee said to Srila Prabhupada in a incredulous way , “Do you know that these young boys and girls actually worship you?” Srila Prabhupada responded in a matter of fact way, “Yes this is our system, I am also worshiping my Guru Maharaja.”
I worship Srila Prabhupada as good as God, even today, because I have full faith that he is my ever well wisher, that he would never cheat me, and that his advice is as good as if God is directly instructing me. I am convinced that by worshiping him I please Lord Krishna more then if I tried to worship Krishna directly, jumping over, or eliminating Srila Prabhupada.
We have seen in Iskcon how misuse of this philosophy has created havoc by those who thought that they were gurus but who in reality did not posses the qualification to be a guru. So how to proceed so as not to let this unhappy history repeat itself? First of all those who are taking this responsibility of bringing people into the sampradaya should always be conscious of the fact that they are not actually qualified to do so. It is only Srila Prabhupada’s mercy in the form of his society, his books, his followers and he himself personally that brings prospective disciples to the Iskcon gurus. Therefore we we should be careful not to insist that our disciples have to see “us” as good as God unless of course we happen to be as good as God. I for one do not tell those who are under my care that they have to see me as good as God. What I suggest to them is they see me according to my adhikary or position of spiritual advancement. Although this may prove somewhat problematic for them, this problem can be resolved if we all agree to keep Srila Prabhupada in the center, and cooperate together for serving his mission. Srila Prabhupada was happy if his disciples saw him as good as God because he was as good as God. I can not honestly say the same.
That does not mean that Srila Prabhupada was God, but he was always purely executing the will of God and by fully surrendering ourselves to him, God is more please with us then if we try to directly serve Him.
In summary we can say that Srila Prabhupada was especially empowered by Krishna to establish this Krishna conscious movement all over the world, and if we assist him in this mission then we will get his mercy. If we can get Srila Prabhupada’s mercy then we will surely get Krishna’s mercy and thus our mission in life will be successful and we will all keep our connection with Srila Prabhupada now, and after we give up this body.
Gurukula is considered important in our tradition so that the boy will get the proper spiritual training in his formative years. Because of bodily attachment one’s father is not considered as the best person to impart this training. A qualified guru who is perfectly able to deal with all in an even handed way is more ideal for this training.
Yours sincerely,
Trivikrama Swami